“So, if you’re so good at SEO, I should be able to google “Chicago SEO consuktant” and see you right at the top, right?”
It wasn’t the first time I’d been asked this.
But hopefully, it’d be the last.
In fact, this wasn’t even the first time somebody had falsely associated being good at SEO with being ranked #1 for [insert most obvious keyword here].
When I first started my jiu jitsu gi company in 2012. I talked to another brand owner with more experience in SEO and he told me that he used to rank #1 for “jiu jitsu gi” and it brought in almost no sales.
He said that people wanted to compare uniforms and he was better off helping a store that carried his brand rank for that term, than himself. Additionally, the sales that it did bring in, often wanted to return gis at a higher rate than other buyers (great for a big store, bad for a small brand).
I’ve always felt the same about the SEO industry and “SEO” keywords.
By “SEO” keywords, I mean ranking for keywords like:
- Backlinks
- City+ SEO
- What is SEO?
- SEO tips
- SEO tools
- Free SEO tools
- SEO tolls (not a thing. Just wanted to see if you were paying attention).
What people outside our industry fail to realize is that ranking for these keywords is not a sign of skill. It’s a pissing contest between SEOs to see who can get the most backlinks to their blog about SEO from other backlink SEO blogs.
I believe it’s both a ton of work, and worth very little unless you’re trying to sell a course on SEO based on how well your website ranks for SEO terms. It’s the same as the most popular YouTube channel about starting a YouTube channel.
In fact, here’s the REAL results of ranking on the first page for “Chicago seo consultant” for over a year:
So more recently, when I was reading a great article about SEO and I noticed there was a Click-to-Tweet link that said something to the effect of “click here to see why I don’t rank for Philadelphia SEO,” I couldn’t resist clicking and tweeting:
Hey @nick_eubanks why is it a complete waste of time to rank for local seo service keywords? #FailboatSEO #CauseTheyCheapBastards
— Brendan 👉 FOLLOW ME ON THREADS & LINKEDIN ⚡️ (@BrendanHufford) March 7, 2018
But, when I searched the hashtags attached, I found a previous tweet Nick had answered that brought me a bit further down the path of how I was considering things.
These searches are done by the least sophisticated clients… the leads they generate will always have the smallest budget and take the most of your time.
More sophisticated queries lead to more sophisticated clients (and bigger budgets)
— nick Ξubanks (@nick_eubanks) February 19, 2018
Maybe I wasn’t so crazy for thinking it’s a waste to try to rank for those search terms. I reached out to Nick directly and here’s what he said (emphasis mine):
“Back in the day when I had my first ever agency, I thought ranking for local service terms was really important. We helped rank local service keywords for lawyers, accounts, dentists, and plumbers – and I saw first hand the leads it generated, so why wouldn’t it be the same for SEO.
Because unlike other local services, where the client doesn’t need to be educated (which tends to be the case for folks turning to Google to find vendors), having uneducated clients in SEO makes your job twice as hard.
Once upon a time, my first agency (atomni) ranked #1 for a handful of “SEO Philadelphia” and “SEO companies Philadelphia” terms, and they were, by far, the worst leads. Beyond simply not understanding why I couldn’t rank them #1 for all the keywords they wanted within 1 month, these people always had next to no budget and couldn’t understand why the service would cost anymore than $200, at best.” – Nick Eubanks, From the Future
I’m a member of Traffic Think Tank (TTT), of which Nick is a co-founder, so I wanted to see what the other two co-founders had to say.
I first reached out to Ian Howells. Ian’s bio reads as follows:
His agency work began in 2007, eventually landing him at Red Ventures where he managed a book of business worth millions per month. He now leads SEO at LendingTree, where his career depends on ranking for terms like “car loans” and “debt consolidation.”
So I don’t feel bad admitting Ian has forgotten more about SEO than I know.
“All of my consulting interest comes from either people in my network or current clients. Trying to rank for stuff like “Charlotte SEO” feels like something that would just lead to a lot of leads coming in who likely don’t really understand SEO or what would be involved.
If you’re up for doing lots of education in the sales process, or have figured out a way to really work through a lead pipeline to filter to just what you want, it could be worth it. For me, that’s so far from what I want to be spending time on that targeting those terms isn’t even a think I think about at all.” – Ian Howells SEO Director – Lending Tree / Partner – Traffic Think Tank
Another confirmation.
Which led me to Matt, former Global Head of SEO (and current Director of Acquisition) for Hubspot:
“Honestly, the amount of time and resources that you’d invest in going after those broad terms is likely not worth it – the exception being that it can be worth going after the location-based terms if you’re focused on selling local SEO services, or just want to own this from a branding play.
From my experience, you’ll generate much more qualified and generally higher quality leads from search if you bring them into informational content, like case studies, etc. that show off your expertise.” – Matthew Howells-Barby, Director of Acquisition – Hubspot / Partner – Traffic Think Tank
I wanted to reach out to two other super-smart SEO experts, so I started with Tony Gilbert, who not only contributes some of the most thoughtful responses in TTT, but also doesn’t pull any punches.
“In terms of time & money spent, one could probably get many more leads by educating others, attending conferences, and personal networking, in place of chasing highly competitive terms with traditional SEO. Going the “belly-to-belly” route is easier & cheaper (and more fun?) compared to sitting behind a keyboard; and, I’d argue, increases your leverage in the long-run, regardless of whether or not you’re visible in Google.
If someone had crazy budgets, then I might say “go for it.” But for those of us in the real world, we usually have to find creative ways to navigate around these top-level money terms.” – Tony Gilbert, RealFX
I think very highly of the team at Siege Media, having read a few of their articles and believe it’s no surprise the content they create for their clients ranks so well. I reached out to Ross, from Siege, with the same questions. Is it worth it to rank for broad SEO-terms or for local SEO searches?
“I think generally, services pages send low quality leads. One reason is these are “comparison searches”. As a service vendor, you don’t want to be comparison shopped, you want to be the go-to. That comes from thought leadership, which is why I do think ranking for some bigger SEO keywords and-or long tail can’t hurt. You’re unlikely to get leads that second, but you can move them into the long-term funnel by following you and/or signing up for your email list, which can be valuable down the line.
I think it’s still worth trying to rank for those keywords, as sure, why not, because everyone needs a service page regardless so you might as well align it to your location+offering. But yeah, I wouldn’t recommend anyone lose sleep over the lack of ranking or slave too hard to get it.” – Ross Hudgens, Siege Media
Finally, Nick Leroy added some great insights:
“As someone who ranked #1 for “Minneapolis SEO” for nearly 2 years, I can validate that it drove little to no leads. The leads that it did drive, were very similar to Nick Eubanks (quoted above) in that it drove very low-quality leads. If I’m being completely honest, it was a pure ego stroking ranking. Nowadays I’d much rather cash checks then puff my chest out ranking for ‘trophy keywords'”. – Nick LeRoy
So maybe I’m not insane. I was totally ready to be proven wrong on this point and be told, “No, I’ve ranked for those high-level SEO terms and they were totally worth it.”
But they aren’t.
- They’re a race to the bottom and commoditize your business.
- It costs a lot of time and/or money to rank for them.
- The leads they bring in are poor.
- They’re literally only useful if you’re looking to sell a course on backlinks to a group of people that are impressed that you rank first for “backlinks.”
And since I think that’s both stupid and a colossal waste of time. I’m out.
In the meantime, I’ll be over here writing (and ranking for) things that actually help people.
Thanks for including my thoughts… especially with folks smarter than myself. 😉
Yep… ranking for “vanity” keywords is usually a waste of time (and money).
I’ve never been more honored to have a tweet of mine screenshotted and included in a blog.
I work at an agency in Greenville, South Carolina and I’ve wrestled with this since I first got Nick’s reply on Twitter. I’ll admit I’ve sunk a lot of time into ranking for all of our “trophy keywords” including SEO + city, and I think you’re absolutely right. For others: web design + city, google ads + city– we have had some quality leads and clients. But if I had to guess, a searcher is already familiar with us due to our reputation or our content prior to making that search and converting.
Great stuff, Brendan.
Hey Brendan, great stuff and I think you’re right with everything here at face value…rank #1 for “SEO agency” or “SEO company” or whatever and you get phonecalls from immature buyers who commoditise you, ask for discounts and compare you with cheap imitations of your product – but SEO is a long game, as we’re fond of saying…and you know what they buy isn’t going to work.
So:
1. Make sure you know every decision maker behind that RFP and meet them (or don’t waste your time responding)
2. Tell them why their way isn’t going to work and, more importantly, tell them how your way is bulletproof
3. Give them a quote/proposal for exactly what they need, not what they’re asking for
4. Walk away when you don’t win
5. Watch them waste small amounts of money
6. Call back and remind them what they needed to do – I’m fond of consistently sending Searchmetrics graphs and asking “this is what I’m seeing, does that match up with sales?”
7. Close at the right price in a non-competitive proposal.
If you rank really well you can do this consistently. I do. There are bigger agencies than mine…but it was 15 years before we felt we needed to start outbound sales.
Delicious article! Thanks bro.
Wow, this is a much-needed read for many marketers I know (and not only marketers!). I agree with pretty much all you said, and it’s hard to believe how many people still don’t understand the nature of SEO and how it converts in real life.
I shared it on our Twitter, here at Nightwatch.io, because I think that more people need to realize what you have written about.
Now this is definitely something worth reading! I think you make great points here, basically the general idea for all our marketing efforts is to convert leads to consumers and retain them as loyal customers, SEO can rank your business on top searches but it definitely needs a follow through.
Ranking for trophy KWs, the leads they bring in are poor, I agree to some degree!
Thanks for this well written and referenced article. You confirmed my suspicions. We recently rebuilt our website, a painstaking process that took well over a year. We focused more on presenting value, creating a unique brand identity, and user experience and conversion rate optimization.
This was very helpful. Thanks so much!
It was a very useful article. Thanks for your detailed explanation!
Thank you for the helpful content!
Complete disgrace of a company.
At one time, I bought many followers for accounts on Instagram, which I do. But only on this site, I’m guaranteed to get real active follower who likes and reviews material in the accounts I do.
THANK YOU FOR THIS ARTICLE!!
Güvenilir bir sağlayıcıdan Instagram takipci satın al. Bugün dünyadaki en iyi sosyal medya hizmetleri sağlayıcılarından biriyiz.Instagram beğeni satın al. Şirketimiz uzun yıllardır faaliyet gösteriyor ve hizmetlerimizden memnun olan binlerce müşteriye hizmet verdik.
Kriptoks Keşfet
Popilero’yu ziyaret ederek bütçenize ve tarzınıza en uygun hediye kutusuna sahip olabilirsiniz. Bunun için hiç vakit kaybetmeden linke tıklayabilirsiniz.
Pinbahis giriş adresi bahis sektöründe çığır açmaya devam ediyor. Sen de bahis oyunları ile keyifli ve kazançlı anlar geçirmek istiyorsan linke tıkla!
Asyahis giriş adresi düzenlemiş olduğu bonus ve kampanyalar sayesinde kullanıcılarının bahis deneyimlerine renk katmaktadır. Sen de linke tıkla ve Asyahis’in avantajlarından yararlan!
An IP stresser is a tool designed to test a network or server for robustness. The administrator may run a stress test in order to determine whether the existing resources (bandwidth, CPU, etc.) are sufficient to handle additional load.
Sekabet giriş adresi sayesinde yüzlerce çeşit ve birbirinden kaliteli bahis oyunlarını bir arada deneyimleyebilirsiniz. Linke tıkla, kayıt ol ve eşsiz vakitler geçirmeye başla!
– You can use the Hidden Wiki site to browse the internet without sharing your location information. You can find suggestions on how to use a VPN on the site.
– It is possible to browse the Internet without dealing with cookies. You can choose the Hidden Wiki site to get this experience.
You can use the Hidden Wiki site to browse the internet without sharing your location information. You can find suggestions on how to use a VPN on the site.
StarkGuardians is the leading multi-chain NFT audit provider and security research platform.
An IP stresser is a tool designed to test a network or server for robustness. The administrator may run a stress test in order to determine whether the existing resources (bandwidth, CPU, etc.) are sufficient to handle additional load.
I like your content very much. You visit again. Thanks for the article
İroko deck, İroko deck fiyat, iroko deck m2 fiyat, Ahşap Deck m2 fiyatı, Kompozit Deck m2 fiyatı, Ahşap Deck Fiyatları, Kompozit Deck m2 fiyatı İzmir, Ahşap Deck, Ahşap deck m2 fiyat, Teak deck, Teak deck m2 fiyat, Thermowood deck fiyat
Ev içi ahşap merdiven modelleri, Ahşap Merdiven Fiyatları, Beton üstü Ahşap merdiven fiyatları, Villa ahşap merdiven modelleri, Ev içi Ahşap Merdiven Fiyatları, Ahşap merdiven modelleri, Duvara saplamalı merdiven, Hayalet merdiven, Demir merdiven ahşap kaplama, Lake Merdiven Beyaz
web sitesi kurmak için hemen ziyaret et!
ver good nice blog page
Hello, I had the opportunity to visit your site and review your content. The content of your site is great. I will visit again later and leave nice comments.
This is exactly what I needed to read today Your words have given me a new perspective and renewed hope Thank you
Presa din Romania Presa Online, stiri news din Romania Presa din Romania.
Immersing myself in positive quotes really brightens my day. Their emphasis on a spiritual, uplifting journey truly resonates with me.
As someone who struggles with mental health, I appreciate the support and empathy displayed in your blog It means a lot to know I’m not alone
Thank you for always being open and honest with your readers It’s refreshing to see a blogger who is unafraid to be vulnerable and real
This blog is a great mix of informative and entertaining content It keeps me engaged and interested from start to finish
This article makes a compelling argument against focusing on SEO “trophy keywords.” It’s a refreshing perspective that highlights the importance of targeting more specific, long-tail keywords that are less competitive and more likely to convert. The emphasis on understanding user intent and creating content that addresses the needs of your audience is spot-on. This strategy not only improves your chances of ranking but also enhances the overall user experience on your site. Thanks for shedding light on this often-overlooked aspect of SEO!
This was very helpful. Thanks
Your in-depth analysis of subject is much appreciated It’s clear you put a lot of thought into this post
nöbetçi dişçi için doğru adres
Thank you, it is a quality and nice content.
Your post on topic was very informative I learned a lot from your detailed explanation
Hi I Love Your Site
This was beautiful Admin. Thank you for your reflections.
very informative articles or reviews at this time.
It was a nice share, I liked it very much. You can check out our website.
It was a nice share, I liked it very much. You can check out our website.
Hello, both the content and visuals of your site are extraordinary. I am the web designer of the Official Website of Kadıköy Böcek İlaçlama Şirketi , which provides House Disinfestation services in Kadıköy, Istanbul.
Türkiye’nin en güncel bahis adreslerini takip edin.
En iyi Türkiye bahis siteleri, bir tık uzağınızda.
Türkiye’nin en iyi oranları sunan bahis sitesine üye olun.
Türkiye’deki en popüler bahis siteleri sizi bekliyor.
Türkiye’deki bahis sitelerinin en yeni giriş adreslerine hemen ulaşın.
Türkiye’deki en iyi oranları sunan bahis sitesine üye olun.
Yeni giriş adresiyle bahis keyfine devam edin.
Yüksek kazançlı bahisler burada sizi bekliyor.
Mobil uyumlu bahis sitesi ile her yerde bahis yapın.
Bahis tutkunları için en iyi adres burada.
Mobil uyumlu bahis sitesi ile her an bahis yapın.
Bahis tutkunları için en iyi adres burada.
Bahis tutkunları için en iyi adres burada.
Hızlı ve güvenli bahis deneyimi sizi bekliyor.
Türkiye’nin lider bahis sitesinde şansınızı deneyin.
Canlı bahis için en iyi adres burada.
Türkiye’nin en kazandıran bahis sitesi burada.
Yasal bahis keyfi için buraya göz atın.
It was a nice share, I liked it very much. You can check out our website.
It was a nice share, I liked it very much. You can check out our website.
Hiring https://contractorfinder.geappliances.com/contractors was a game-changer as a service to my poorhouse renovation project. From the initial consultation to the terminating walkthrough, their professionalism and adroitness were evident. The conspire was communicative, ensuring I was educated at every stage. Their heed to delegate was unblemished, transforming my vision into reality with precision. Teeth of a occasional unexpected challenges, they adapted unexpectedly, keeping the project on track. The characteristic of work exceeded my expectations, making the investment worthwhile.